Domain Name And Internet Articles

"Digital Pamphleteer" Appeals Web-Censorship Case, Seeks Injunction Against City Policy That Halted Web Publishing For Non-Profit Library Website

(PRWEB) February 13, 2008 -- The shutdown of an Oregon non-profit organization's website by the City of Ashland, Oregon has sparked a legal feud that is bringing an important Internet law issue before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco: Can a City that operates a municipal Internet service be sued over a City policy that allowed a City technician to turn off a web-server's access to the Internet without notifying the website operator? Cyberlawyer Charles Carreon has just filed a brief on the issue for the non-profit organization, arguing that the City's action raises the spectre of censorship, is facially unconstitutional, and was applied to shut off his client's website as punishment for posting a risque political cartoon of conservative columnist Kathleen Parker.

"All American Buddha wanted was to publish its website on the City of Ashland's municipal fibernet, without interference from a censor inside some City department." That's how Charles Carreon, the lawyer for the American Buddha Online Library, explained his client's lawsuit against the City of Ashland, that has now reached the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Appealing from an Oregon district court decision that ruled against its complaint, American Buddha filed its Opening Brief on February 11th, asking the appellate court to rule "de novo" on the issue, and strike down an Ashland city policy that allowed a City technician total authority to turn off websites that had been the subject of a purported copyright infringment complaint. "It was particularly offensive," says Carreon, "that the City policy didn't require that anyone even attempt to contact the website operator before turning off their website. In my client's case, website publication was halted for an hour before I was able to get the City to restart it. There was a serious chilling effect on speech from that shutoff -- a real fear that the censors would be watching, and shutting the website down again in the future. That's why we had to file suit."

"Internet censorship is just the latest outbreak of a disease that government always suffers from -- wanting to control what people can say," says Carreon, "We are shining a light on a problem that no one in Ashland knew about -- the existence of a censor inside of the City who could, and did, turn off websites for totally improper reasons. In the case of American Buddha, it was a complaint from conservative columnist Kathleen Parker, who was the subject of a risque cartoon that was posted on the American Buddha website http://www.american-buddha.com. In other cases, we don't know what the reasons were, but the websites were turned off."

Ashland, Oregon became one of the first cities to build its own connection to the Internet, going live with its Ashland Fiber Net (AFN) in 1999. Chronically over budget and behind schedule on construction, AFN was a magnet for critics. VIrtually since the project began City government has been smarting from citizen criticism that it was a service that regular people didn't need, and that regular taxpayers didn't want to sponsor for a clique of high-tech upstarts. AFN supporters have repeatedly argued that the benefits of the service for the people, and the growth of high-tech business in the city, vastly outweigh the costs of operation. For years City administrators complained that under-cutting by local cable provider Charter Communications prevented its cable TV business from taking off. Recently the TV operation was spun off to a private operator.

The local Internet service, however, is firmly in City hands, and that, says Carreon, is central to his case. "State action is the key," said Carreon. "In most cases, the provider of Internet access is through some private company -- one of the big telecommunications companies. They don't have First Amendment obligations. The CIty of Ashland is different. It is the government, and it chose to go into the business of allowing people to publish websites on their network. Once government opens up a public forum like that, they have to obey the First Amendment -- they can't appoint censors."

According to the Director of American Buddha, an Internet librarian who goes by the name "Ambu Fortuna," the Oregon non-profit filed the lawsuit "to protect our mission to share free speech with members around the world." The website has been in operation since year 2000, and has well over fifty-thousand members, according to Fortuna, who described the library's collection and her user base: "Our website is one of the only places where you can read rare political books without being asked for money. Some of those books, like 'The Trail of the Octopus,' by Lester Coleman, a former DIA agent, that tells the uncensored history of the Lockerbie / PanAm airliner bombing, and can't be found anywhere for less than several hundred dollars a copy. Students, teachers, and researchers use our website for serious study. So having the City of Ashland blocking publication based on a complaint from a right-wing writer was blatant political censorship. For the sake of our readers, and the cause of free speech, I had to sue." An online archive of legal documents is available at http://www.american-buddha.com/ambuvs.city.toc.htm. American Buddha v. City of Ashland, U.S. Court of Appeals Case No. 07-035721.

Asked why the case was important enough to justify an appeal to the Ninth Circuit, a project that can easily cost a client a healthy five-figure sum, Carreon explained: "The issue is one of first-impression, because whether a municipal Internet system subjects a city to First Amendment restrictions is, strictly speaking, a new one. On the other hand, it's just a replay of the old Jehovah's WItness cases, where an unpopular religion found its message blocked by restrictions on the use of loudspeakers and pamphleteering. American Buddha is a digital pamphleteer, entitled to the same protections as the works of the Founding Fathers, who wrote 'The Federalist Papers' pseudonymously, and circulated them secretly to avoid Royal prosecution. The Revolutionary War was in large part, a war against censorship. And it's not over."

###

Other Article Sites

findabook.com  moneycd.info  a-mortgage.info   about-lemon-laws.info  aboutstudentloans.info
all-about-publishing.info  auctions-articles.info  bestcollege-university.com  bestispconnection.com
biblefolder.com  blogger-website.com  books-used.info  brokers-guide.info  buywindows.info  cable-dsl.info
career-miner.com  carpel-tunnel.info  cashinaflash.info  cashloanreviews.info  casinobell.com  chat-house.info
clearmycredit.info  collegeloantips.info  crones.info  depression-articles.info   dirnic.net  dishguides.info
divers-below.com  expodog.info   financewizz.com  fire-insurance.info  getgood.info  handleit.net   it-idea.info
health-supplies.info  hosting-right.com  insidealert.com  insurance-facts.info  jobs-employment.info
justgood.info  lookgold.net   lowcost-travel.info  money-source.info  myhostzone.info  numisblog.com
peoplesearchfinder.info  pr-articles.info  realeas.com   refinancing-guides.info  spyware-remove.info
telelot.info  the-law.info   toppaid.info  travel-deals.info  travelcorrect.com  wedding-guide-site.com
your-blog.info  your-credit.info

MORE ARTICLES:

IonCube Technology & How Encoding Can Secure Your Web Code
What is IonCube? Quite simply IonCube is a software product packaged and sold by IonCube, a company based in the United Kingdom. The software is specifically designed to protect software or scripts written using the PHP programming language from being altered in any way. This means they cannot be viewed, changed, or run on unlicensed computers.

The Rich Jerk Review: New Agressive and Effective Internet Marketing Methods for All
The Rich Jerk "Making Money on the internet is Easy" e-book Review1)The value proposition The Rich Jerk claims:* To reveal the unorthodox marketing methods that brought him million dollars each year* That most of his techniques have never been seen* That he is better than you because he's richer!2)The Rich Jerk e-book description* 40 pages* 8 chapters covering the topic "Make Money on the internet"* Filled with The Rich Jerk personal experiences, tips and tricks to cover the "is Easy" topic* Written in a direct and clear style to go straight to the point* For 97$* 45 days money back guarantee (the Rich Jerk offers 200% refunds under conditions)3)The perceived valuei-Overall opinionAn outstanding ressource that covers in a synthetic style th...

Big Business Web Design Disasters
When you think of the world's most successful businesses, what names come to mind? Most likely, consumer-oriented giants such as Coca-Cola, McDonald's, Sheraton, Disney, IBM, and General Electric. Not only have they spent billions on advertising to buy their way into your head. They offer convenient products and services that have made them a part of your life.

Getting Started With Internet Marketing
I used to have an e-commerce website where I sold espresso machines, coffee makers, and coffees. It was only mildly successful, despite the current demand for the product in the US. I wasted a ridiculous amount of time and money on CPC advertising, 3rd party SEO optimization, low quality advertising, and etc. Want to know why I wasn?t more successful? Traffic?or the lack thereof. I eventually dropped that website and decided to pursue new paths, namely internet marketing. Let me tell you, I sure wish I knew then what I know now about the internet. I could have easily been ten times more successful simply because I have learned how to get quality traffic to a site. If you are just getting started online (whether it be affiliate marketing or ...

Promoting Home Business: Tips to Increase Web Site Sales
You've selected an appropriate Online Business Opportunity. That is not ALL!To run a successful online ecommerce Home business, getting the targetted users to visit your site and converting them into customers is the first and foremost thing.

Choosing the Right Type of Internet Marketing
One of the most difficult things in Internet marketing is trying to figure out the best way to tell people about what you have. If you make the wrong decision, it can have disastrous results. So here are a few things to think about when you are looking for an Internet marketing plan. They will help you to take a look at what you are trying to do and who you are trying to reach, and make the right decision for you and for your business.

Dave Lukow's NFL Daily Dish Places Men's Fantasy Sports Web Site at the Top of the Fantasy League Heap; Site Offers Free Membership for Sign
Mensfantasysports.com sets the pace with expert fantasy football picks as the NFL draft approaches. Celebrity handicapper Cindy Margolis has joined the MSF team.

WWW should mean Win Win Web before the pigs have wings.
At the time of Internet's Big Bang, everything was free, open, to give and to take for the ones who needed.Now we live the Age of Internet's Big Bank.

Custom Web Site Builder Considerations - Looking For Easy Programs
In todays technologically advanced marketplace there are several affordable Custom Web Site Builder programs offered. These software programs offer a extensive array of tools and devices through which a person can design and put up a website that is perfectly suited for personal or business use.

Corporate Internet Branding — Branding Your Business Online
Let me tell you a story about Pete and a pizza. After a long day of fighting uncooperative pipes and fixtures, Pete P.

Web Development Outsourcing
With the increasing demand of Web Development Outsourcing services, it has become essential for organizations to select an efficient outsourcing company that will work productively to provide good results in a specific time period. It is important to look for a service provider with good experience and understanding of the industry and who can offer a wide range of solutions.

Bound To Your Old Expensive Web Host by Fear?
You're not alone! Many people are bound to the old web host they've used for years because they're afraid of the hassle of switching. Customers will pay rates three or four or even ten times greater than what they have to, just because they're terrified that switching will be too complicated or that they'll end up losing their site altogether.

Meaning of Web Site Design
A web site is a collection of information about a particular topic or subject. Web site design is defined as the arrangement and creation of web pages that in turn make up a web site. A web page consists of information for which the website is designed and developed. For example, a web site might be compared to a book, where each page of the book is a web page.

Diabetes Social Network Wins Web 2.0 Award for Niche Social Networks
TuDiabetes.com, a social network for people touched by diabetes dubbed "MySpace on Insulin," was awarded second place for the Niche Social Network category as part of the 2008 Web 2.0 Awards.

Front Service Technology Update: The Hottest New Site on the Web by Service Tracking Systems, Inc.
Valet parking technology, access control, license plate recognition and count systems don't have to be as boring as they sound. Servicetrackingsystems.net takes front services technologies to another level. Computerized Valet Parking Systems invented and perfected vehicle imaging for damage assessment and the valet management system we know today. Now Service Tracking Systems offers truly integrated solutions for ALL parking, valet parking, perimeter access, and front service needs.